Time Management Isn't What You Think It Is: Why Most Advice is Rubbish

Connect with us: SB Nation | Medium | Poodle Forum | Garden Tractor Talk | Quora

My receptionist walked into my office at 3:47 PM last Thursday with that look on her face. You know the one. The "I've been trying to manage my time better but I'm drowning" expression that I've seen on thousands of faces over my 18 years as a workplace trainer.

"I've tried everything," she said, waving a colour-coded planner that looked like a rainbow exploded. "The Pomodoro Technique, time-blocking, priority matrices. Nothing works."

Here's the thing about time management that nobody wants to tell you: it's not about managing time at all. Time moves at exactly the same pace for everyone. What we're really talking about is energy management, attention management, and quite frankly, getting better at saying no to stupid requests.

The Productivity Guru Industrial Complex Has Failed You

Walk into any Dymocks and you'll find 47 different books promising to revolutionise your relationship with time. Most of them are written by people who've never managed anything more complex than their own speaking calendar.

I've been training people in organisational skills for nearly two decades, and here's what I've learned: the people who struggle most with time management are usually the most conscientious employees. They're trying to do everything perfectly instead of doing the right things well enough.

Take Sarah from my Melbourne workshop last month. Senior marketing coordinator, colour-coded everything, arrived early, stayed late. Completely burnt out because she was treating every email like a bushfire emergency. Meanwhile, Dave from the same company gets twice as much done and leaves at 5 PM sharp because he's figured out that 73% of "urgent" requests aren't actually urgent at all.

Dave's secret? He batch-processes emails twice a day and has trained his colleagues not to expect instant responses. Revolutionary stuff, really.

Why Your Morning Routine is Probably Making Things Worse

Instagram productivity influencers love banging on about 5 AM wake-ups and cold showers. As if becoming a morning masochist is the key to professional success.

Here's a controversial opinion: if you're not naturally a morning person, forcing yourself into a morning routine is like trying to fit a square peg into a round hole. I've worked with night owls who do their best strategic thinking at 2 PM and early birds who can't string a coherent sentence together after lunch.

Work with your natural rhythms, not against them.

My mate Tony runs a successful plumbing business and doesn't touch his phone until 8 AM. His mornings are for the workshop and planning the day's jobs. Emails happen after lunch when his energy naturally dips. Simple system, works perfectly.

Compare that to the marketing exec I met in Brisbane who was trying to meditate at 5:30 AM before hitting the gym, making bulletproof coffee, and journaling her gratitudes. She lasted three weeks before crashing harder than the Australian dollar in 2008.

The Real Time Thieves Nobody Talks About

Everyone knows about social media and endless meetings. But the biggest time thieves in most workplaces are:

Perfectionism masquerading as quality control. I see this constantly in professional services. Junior lawyers spending six hours perfecting a one-page brief that the partner will rewrite anyway. Accountants triple-checking calculations that the software already verified.

Good enough is usually good enough. Perfect is the enemy of done, and all that.

The "quick question" culture. Open plan offices are productivity graveyards because of this. Every interruption costs you roughly 23 minutes to get back into deep focus. I'm not making that up – it's from research by the University of California, Irvine. Although honestly, it feels longer when someone's asking about the birthday cake roster for the third time this week.

Saying yes to everything because you want to be helpful. This one's particularly brutal for women in the workplace. Research shows they're asked to do administrative tasks and "office housework" far more often than men. The solution isn't working harder; it's developing better communication skills to push back professionally.

The Australian Approach to Time Management

Here's something I've noticed working across Australia and internationally: we've got this cultural thing about being laid-back, but it often translates into poor boundaries at work. We'll stay back to help a colleague, agree to unrealistic deadlines to avoid conflict, and answer emails at all hours because we don't want to seem precious.

This isn't being a good team player. It's being a mug.

The most successful people I know – from Perth tech startups to Sydney law firms – are actually quite ruthless about protecting their time. They're just polite about it.

Take James, who runs a construction company in Adelaide. He's known for delivering projects on time and under budget. His secret? He builds buffer time into everything and doesn't tell clients about it. When delays happen (and they always do), he absorbs them without stress. When they don't, he looks like a miracle worker.

Smart operators like James understand that time management is really about expectation management.

The Three-Bucket System That Actually Works

Forget complex productivity systems. Most people need something simple enough to remember when they're stressed, tired, or dealing with a crisis.

I teach a three-bucket approach:

Bucket 1: Must Do Today (Maximum 3 items) These are the tasks that will cause genuine problems if they're not completed. Not "it would be nice" tasks. Actual problems.

Bucket 2: Should Do This Week (5-7 items) Important but not urgent. The stuff that moves your career or business forward.

Bucket 3: Everything Else The wish list. The someday maybe pile. The things you'll get to when buckets 1 and 2 are empty (which is never).

Most people's daily to-do lists look like bucket 3 masquerading as bucket 1. That's why they feel overwhelmed and unproductive even when they're busy all day.

Technology: Friend or Foe?

I'm probably showing my age here, but I remember when having a mobile phone was optional. Now we carry these productivity-destroying devices everywhere and wonder why we can't focus.

The solution isn't going full digital detox – unless you're running a pottery studio in Byron Bay, you need technology to do your job. But you can absolutely train yourself to use it more intentionally.

My phone lives in a drawer during focused work time. Revolutionary, I know. But it works because out of sight really is out of mind for most people.

I also use what I call "communication windows." I check and respond to messages at 9 AM, 1 PM, and 4 PM. That's it. Emergencies can call. Everything else can wait.

This horrifies some people. "But what if something urgent comes up?"

Here's the thing: most "urgent" communication isn't actually urgent. It's just someone else's poor planning becoming your emergency.

The Meeting Problem

Speaking of other people's poor planning – let's talk about meetings. The average Australian office worker spends 67% of their time in meetings or preparing for meetings. I'm not sure where that statistic comes from, but it feels about right based on the horror stories I hear.

Bad meetings are time theft, pure and simple. And the worst part? We've all become complicit in this theft by accepting meeting invitations without pushing back.

Start asking these questions:

• What's the desired outcome of this meeting?
• Could this be an email instead?
• Why am I specifically needed here?

You'd be amazed how many meetings disappear when you start asking for basic information like agendas and objectives.

I worked with a pharmaceutical company in Sydney where the marketing team was spending 34 hours a week in meetings. Thirty-four hours! That's almost the entire working week before they'd done any actual marketing.

After some basic training on meeting management, they cut it down to 12 hours and saw their campaign output double. Not rocket science, just common sense applied consistently.

Energy Management vs. Time Management

Here's where most productivity advice goes wrong: it assumes you have consistent energy throughout the day. You don't. Nobody does.

I'm a morning person, unfortunately. My brain works best between 7 AM and 11 AM. After lunch, I'm basically useless for anything requiring creativity or complex thinking. So I schedule my writing, planning, and strategic work for mornings. Afternoons are for emails, admin, and catching up with people.

This seems obvious, but most people fight against their natural energy patterns instead of working with them.

If you're useless until 10 AM, stop scheduling 8 AM brainstorming sessions. If you crash after lunch, don't book important client calls at 2 PM. If you get a second wind around 4 PM, save some meaningful work for then instead of just clearing your inbox.

The Delegate or Die Principle

One of the biggest time management mistakes I see is people trying to do everything themselves. This is particularly common with small business owners and new managers who haven't learned to let go yet.

Delegation isn't about dumping unwanted tasks on junior staff. It's about matching tasks to the right skill level and freeing yourself up for work that only you can do.

I remember working with a financial advisor in Melbourne who was personally responding to every client email, even the simple ones asking for account balances or meeting confirmations. His assistant was perfectly capable of handling 80% of these queries, but he insisted on doing it himself because "it's more personal."

Meanwhile, he was working 60-hour weeks and hadn't taken a proper holiday in three years. We calculated that his "personal touch" was costing him $47,000 a year in lost productivity and stress-related health issues.

Six months after implementing a proper delegation system, his business revenue had increased by 23% and he was working normal hours again. Sometimes being less hands-on actually improves the customer experience.

The Dark Side of Productivity Culture

Before you think I'm completely obsessed with efficiency, let me be clear: productivity culture has gone too far. We've turned human beings into optimization machines and wonder why everyone's anxious and burnt out.

There's something to be said for inefficiency, for wandering conversations, for staring out the window and thinking about nothing in particular. Some of my best ideas have come during unproductive moments.

The goal isn't to squeeze every minute of productivity out of your day. It's to be intentional about how you spend your time so you can actually enjoy your life outside work.

I know plenty of productivity gurus who can tell you exactly how they spend every 15-minute block of their day but couldn't tell you the last time they had a spontaneous conversation with a friend.

Making It Stick

Here's the reality check: reading about time management won't change anything. You need to actually implement systems and stick with them long enough for them to become habits.

Start small. Pick one thing from this article and try it for two weeks. Not five things. One thing.

Maybe it's the three-bucket system. Maybe it's checking emails only twice a day. Maybe it's just asking "what's the desired outcome?" before accepting your next meeting invitation.

The point is to start somewhere instead of trying to overhaul your entire relationship with time overnight.

After 18 years of helping people get more done without losing their sanity, I can tell you this: time management isn't about finding more hours in the day. It's about being more intentional with the hours you already have.

And sometimes, the most productive thing you can do is absolutely nothing at all.